Comment in Support of the Proposed Amendment to M Crim JI 20.31, 20.32, and 20.33
February 27, 2025
This Section supports the proposed amendments to the Model Criminal Jury Instructions 20.31, 20.33 and for the deletion of M Crim JI 20.32, contending this update aligns the instructions with Supreme Court precedent in Lawrence v Texas, 539 US 558 (2003). Antiquated, homophobic statutes such as MCL 750.158 should not be used when other, appropriate charges exist. The Section urges modernization of language across the model instructions—replacing binary pronouns (he/she) with gender-neutral “they/their” in keeping with Michigan Supreme Court Administrative Order 2022-03 and MCR 1.109 to better reflect and respect all gender identities. This Section also recommended amending the MCJI 20.33 use note to read “person who identifies as female” to ensure clarity, inclusivity, and equal access to justice.
Read the full statement here.
